News ·
Patrick Stewart took the villain in TMNT, and left the Turtles to the voice actors
Casting an animated film whose four leads are drawings and carry the picture on voice alone is a problem, and the industry answer in 2007 was to hire famous people and put their names on the poster. The Turtles film that came out that March went the other way with the Turtles, and gave its villain to Patrick Stewart.
Sir Patrick Stewart died on Wednesday at his home in Los Angeles, aged 86. His family announced it the following day on his own Instagram account, saying that he had gone “in the loving care of his beloved wife Sunny, following a brief and poignant journey with Alzheimer’s Disease and Lewy Body Dementia”, and that his “sonorous voice and singular talent will forever be synonymous with indelible performances in every genre”.
In TMNT, the computer-animated film Kevin Munroe wrote and directed for Imagi and Warner Bros., Stewart plays Max Winters, a New York industrialist funding expeditions that keep coming home with things better left where they were found. Winters is a cover. Underneath it he is Yaotl, a warlord who opened a portal three thousand years ago, walked out of it unable to die, and has spent every century since trying to put that right. [1]
Munroe was blunt about how the picture was cast. “It was really important to us to make sure that we didn’t celebrity-cast the Turtle films,” he told Verbicide in March 2007, and in the same answer: “we have Patrick Stewart as our villain Max Winters.” Both of those are true at once. James Arnold Taylor, Nolan North, Mitchell Whitfield and Mikey Kelley took Leonardo, Raphael, Donatello and Michelangelo, four working voice actors in the four leads; the names the marketing could use went to the humans, Sarah Michelle Gellar as April and Chris Evans as Casey, and to Stewart as Winters. [2]
Winters is barely a villain by the time you meet him. Yaotl is not trying to take anything. He is trying to undo something: to break the curse he started, and to give his four stone generals their humanity back. The generals he raised to help him spend the film concealing the fact that they want no such thing, and that they have decided he has gone soft. [3] A part like that asks for weariness rather than menace, but Stewart came to it off twenty years of Jean-Luc Picard, a captain whose crew did what he told them. He stays a villain for most of the running time and then stops being one: he turns on the generals, saves the Turtles, becomes mortal, and dies in the closing minutes of the film. He is very good in it.
The Turtles tend to bring voices back. Rob Paulsen played Raphael in 1987 and returned as Donatello in 2012; our voice cast page is mostly a record of people coming round again, and the film archive is where the one-offs sit. Stewart was a one-off. He came once, played a three-thousand-year-old man who wants to die, and did not come back.
[1] The four are the Stone Generals: Aguila, Gato, Serpiente and Mono, petrified by the same portal that made Yaotl immortal and reanimated centuries later with Winters Industries technology.
[2] Stewart was the first voice the production announced, in 2006, months before any of the four Turtles were named. ComingSoon ran it off the Patrick Stewart Network fansite rather than a studio release.
[3] The generals need thirteen monsters to close the portal and deliberately bring back twelve, planning to feed Leonardo in as the last one so the curse holds and they stay as they are.
Sources: Animation World Network, Animation Magazine, Forbes, TheWrap, Karl Sukhia’s interview with Kevin Munroe, Verbicide, 12 March 2007, ComingSoon, 2006. Key art: still from TMNT, 2007, Imagi Animation Studios / Warner Bros. Pictures.
★ DISCUSSION
Join the conversation.
Comments below are mirrored on the ThunderCats.org forum. Sign in once, post anywhere.